Updated · BreakPoint Research Desk
Most option buyers lose money because an option is a wasting asset: its time value shrinks every day, so the buyer needs the right direction, a large enough move and the right timing — all before expiry. Price must travel beyond the strike plus the premium just to break even, implied volatility can fall after events and cut premiums even when direction is right, and cheap out-of-the-money options rarely finish in the money.
SEBI’s study of FY22–FY24 found that 93% of individual traders in equity F&O made net losses, and a follow-up study for FY25 reported about 91%. Buying options is not automatically wrong, but it needs strict position sizing, a clear catalyst for a fast move and exits that do not wait for expiry.
Key takeaways
In September 2024 SEBI published an updated study showing that 93% of individual traders in the equity F&O segment incurred net losses between FY22 and FY24, with aggregate losses of over ₹1.8 lakh crore across the three years. A study covering FY25, reported in July 2025, found about 91% of individual traders still lost money. SEBI also requires brokers to show risk disclosures to F&O traders.
These figures cover all individual F&O traders, not only option buyers. They show that the default outcome for retail derivatives trading is a loss — so any approach needs a clear reason to be different.
An option’s premium has intrinsic value (how far in the money it is) and time value (what you pay for the chance of a move). Time value falls every day and falls fastest in the final days before expiry. If the move you expect comes late, time decay may have eaten the profit.
Buying a 25,000 call for ₹150 needs the index above 25,150 at expiry just to break even, before charges. A move from 25,000 to 25,100 is “right direction” but still a loss at expiry.
Before results, budgets or policy announcements, implied volatility tends to rise and premiums get expensive. Once the event passes, IV often falls sharply. A buyer who paid a high IV can lose money even if the stock moves in their direction, because the volatility component of the premium collapses.
Far out-of-the-money options cost little because the probability of them finishing in the money is low. Repeatedly buying them feels like limited risk, but frequent small total losses add up.
Brokerage, exchange charges, taxes and bid-ask spreads are paid on every trade. For short-term option buying with small targets, they can be a large share of the expected gain.
Buy for fast moves, not slow ones
Option buying suits situations where a quick, large move is plausible — a breakout with the market behind it — not a slow grind.
Prefer ATM or slightly ITM strikes
They cost more but respond more to the underlying’s move and carry less pure time value than far OTM strikes.
Exit on the underlying, not the premium alone
Define the stop-loss on the index or stock chart and exit when that level breaks, rather than waiting for the premium to recover.
Set a time stop
If the expected move has not happened within your planned time, exit. Waiting is the buyer’s most expensive activity.
Size small
Assume the full premium can go to zero and size so that outcome fits your per-trade risk.
Check IV before events
If IV is elevated ahead of an event, consider that the move may already be priced in.
A trader buys the 25,000 call for ₹150 on a Wednesday with a week to expiry, expecting a rally. Nifty drifts from 25,000 to 25,100 over five sessions.
The view on direction was right, but the move was too small and too slow. At expiry the option is worth only its intrinsic value of ₹100, so the trader loses ₹50 per unit plus costs. Had the trader exited on a time stop after two flat sessions, the loss would have been smaller; had Nifty moved to 25,300 quickly, the trade would have paid.
Option buyers are paid for speed and size of move, not for being right eventually.
Holding into expiry hoping for a recovery
Time decay accelerates; the recovery must be larger every day just to break even.
Averaging down on option premiums
Adding to a decaying position concentrates risk in the asset that loses value fastest.
Buying before results without checking IV
You may be paying for a move that is already priced in.
Choosing strikes by price instead of probability
A ₹5 option is not cheap if it has little chance of finishing in the money.
Trading options without a view on the underlying chart
The option is a way to express a view; the view still has to come from the index or stock.
Assuming option selling is the safe alternative
Selling options collects decay but carries large and sometimes unlimited losses; it needs its own risk controls.
| Check | Why |
|---|---|
| Underlying trend and level | Gives the direction and a stop on the chart |
| Distance to breakeven | Tells you how large a move is needed |
| Days to expiry | Tells you how fast the move must come |
| Implied volatility | Tells you whether options are expensive |
| Option chain OI | Shows where writers may resist the move |
| Scheduled events | Explain IV and the risk of a sharp reversal |
The best improvement for most option buyers is fewer, better trades. BreakPoint gives market and positioning context so you can wait for conditions that suit buying. Its tools do not give buy or sell calls, and how they select instruments stays private.
Where the index is defended
Option Scanner shows where call and put activity is concentrated, so you can see levels a move would need to clear.
Stocks moving with OI behind them
OptionX shows F&O stocks that are moving alongside their open-interest trend (Pro 365).
Is the market trending?
Index Trend shows whether indices are trending or sideways across timeframes — sideways markets are where option buyers lose most to decay.
Log every option trade in Trade Diary, including the days held — it quickly shows whether time decay is where your money goes.
Option buyers in a losing run
Check the breakeven and time-to-expiry of your last ten trades — the pattern is usually obvious.
Beginners
Understand these mechanics before your first option trade, not after.
Stock traders
If you already have a good stock view, consider whether trading the stock itself is a better expression than a decaying option.
Not for
Anyone looking for a way to turn small capital into large returns quickly — options amplify losses as easily as gains.
Pick by workflow, not by feature count. You can change plans later.
Free account
Stay with the guides and paper trades until breakeven, decay and IV feel intuitive.
Free
Breakpoint Pro
Breakpoint Pro includes Option Scanner for index positioning plus Index Trend and Trade Diary.
₹1,299 / 28 days · ₹3,299 / 84 days
Breakpoint Pro 365
Pro 365 adds OptionX and the F&O dashboard suite for stock derivatives context.
₹7,999 / 180 days · ₹15,999 / 365 days
Still unsure? The 60-second product advisor asks four questions about how you trade and recommends one product. Prices as listed on the plans page; always confirm there before paying.
Because options lose time value every day, buyers need the correct direction, a large enough move and good timing before expiry. Breakeven distance, falling implied volatility after events, cheap out-of-the-money strikes and trading costs add to the odds against them.
SEBI’s study covering FY22 to FY24 found 93% of individual equity F&O traders made net losses. A later SEBI study for FY25 reported about 91%.
It can be for some traders in specific situations, especially fast, large moves. For most individual traders it has been loss-making, so it needs strict sizing, clear setups and time-based exits.
Time decay and falling implied volatility can reduce the premium faster than a small favourable move increases it. The move must be large enough and quick enough to outweigh both.
Theta is the rate at which an option loses value as time passes, all else equal. For at-the-money options it accelerates in the final days before expiry.
IV crush is a sharp fall in implied volatility after an expected event such as results. Option premiums drop as a result, which can hurt buyers even if the price moves their way.
Selling benefits from time decay but carries large potential losses when the market moves sharply. Neither side is automatically better; both require risk management.
Many traders prefer at-the-money or slightly in-the-money strikes because they respond more to the underlying’s movement and contain less pure time value than far out-of-the-money strikes.
Check index trend and where options positioning sits before you buy, and log each trade with the days held.
BreakPoint tools open inside your account. If you are not signed in you will be asked to sign in first, and access depends on your active plan. The lessons and guides are free.
Scan the market from your phone — get the BreakPoint app
Terms used here: Delta, Gamma, Theta · Strike Price · Open Interest (OI) · Risk-Reward Ratio · F&O (Futures & Options)
This article is for education only. It is not investment advice or a recommendation to buy or sell any security. Trading involves risk of loss; examples are hypothetical and past behaviour of any pattern does not guarantee future results.